Winners
| Year | Winner | Score | Course | City | St | |
| 1895 | Charles B. | Macdonald | M/P | Newport GC | Newport | RI |
| 1896 | H. J. | Whigham | M/P | Shinnecock Hills GC | Southampton | NY |
| 1897 | H. J. | Whigham | M/P | Chicago GC | Wheaton | Il |
| 1898 | Findlay S. | Douglas | M/P | Morris County GC | Morristown | NJ |
| 1899 | H. M. | Harriman | M/P | Onwentsia Club | Lake Forest | Il |
| 1900 | Walter J. | Travis | M/P | Garden City GC | Garden City | NY |
| 1901 | Walter J. | Travis | M/P | CC of Atlantic City | Atlantic City | NJ |
| 1902 | Louis N. | James | M/P | Glen View Club | Golf | Il |
| 1903 | Walter J. | Travis | M/P | Nassau CC | Glen Cove | NY |
| 1904 | H. Chandler | Egan | M/P | Baltusrol GC | Springfield | NJ |
| 1905 | H. Chandler | Egan | M/P | Chicago GC | Wheaton | Il |
| 1906 | Eben M. | Byers | M/P | Englewood GC | Englewood | NJ |
| 1907 | Jerome | Travers | M/P | Euclid Club | Cleveland | Oh |
| 1908 | Jerome | Travers | M/P | Garden City GC | Garden City | NY |
| 1909 | Robert A. | Gardner | M/P | Chicago GC | Wheaton | Il |
| 1910 | William C. Jr. | Fownes | M/P | The Country Club | Brookline | Ma |
| 1911 | Harold H. | Hilton | M/P | The Apawamis Club | Rye | NY |
| 1912 | Jerome | Travers | M/P | Chicago GC | Wheaton | Il |
| 1913 | Jerome | Travers | M/P | Garden City GC | Garden City | NY |
| 1914 | Francis | Ouimet | M/P | Ekwanok CC | Manchester | Vt |
| 1915 | Robert A. | Gardner | M/P | CC of Detroit | Grosse Pte. Farms | Mi |
| 1916 | Charles (Chick) | Evans | M/P | Merion CC | Ardmore | Pa |
| 1917 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1918 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1919 | S. Davidson | Herron | M/P | Oakmont CC | Oakmont | Pa |
| 1920 | Charles (Chick) | Evans | M/P | Engineers CC | Roslyn | NY |
| 1921 | Jesse P. | Guilford | M/P | St Louis CC | Clayton | Mo |
| 1922 | Jess W. | Sweetser | M/P | The Country Club | Brookline | Ma |
| 1923 | Max R. | Marston | M/P | Flossmoor CC | Flossmoor | Il |
| 1924 | Robert T. (Bobby) Jr. | Jones | M/P | Merion CC | Ardmore | Pa |
| 1925 | Robert T. (Bobby) Jr. | Jones | M/P | Oakmont CC | Oakmont | Pa |
| 1926 | George Von | Elm | M/P | Baltusrol GC | Springfield | NJ |
| 1927 | Robert T. (Bobby) Jr. | Jones | M/P | Minikahda Club | Minneapolis | Mi |
| 1928 | Robert T. (Bobby) Jr. | Jones | M/P | Brae Burn CC | West Newton | Ma |
| 1929 | Harrison R. | Johnston | M/P | Pebble Beach GL | Pebble Beach | Ca |
| 1930 | Robert T. (Bobby) Jr. | Jones | M/P | Merion CC | Ardmore | Pa |
| 1931 | Francis | Ouimet | M/P | Beverly CC | Chicago | Il |
| 1932 | C. Ross | Somerville | M/P | Baltimore CC | Baltimore | Md |
| 1933 | George T. Jr. | Dunlap | M/P | Kenwood CC | Cincinnati | Oh |
| 1934 | Lawson | Little | M/P | The Country Club | Brookline | Ma |
| 1935 | Lawson | Little | M/P | The Country Club | Cleveland | Oh |
| 1936 | John W. | Fischer | M/P | Garden City GC | Garden City | NY |
| 1937 | Johnny | Goodman | M/P | Alderwood CC | Portland | Or |
| 1938 | Willie | Turnesa | M/P | Oakmont CC | Oakmont | Pa |
| 1939 | Marvin H. | Ward | M/P | North Shore CC | Glenview | Il |
| 1940 | Richard | Chapman | M/P | Winged Foot GC | Mamaroneck | NY |
| 1941 | Marvin H. | Ward | M/P | Omaha Field Club | Omaha | Ne |
| 1942 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1943 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1944 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1945 | No Championship Held (War) | |||||
| 1946 | Stanley E. (Ted) | Bishop | M/P | Baltusrol GC | Springfield | NJ |
| 1947 | Robert H. (Skee) | Riegel | M/P | Pebble Beach GL | Pebble Beach | Ca |
| 1948 | Willie | Turnesa | M/P | Memphis CC | Memphis | Tn |
| 1949 | Charles R. | Coe | M/P | Oak Hill CC | Rochester | NY |
| 1950 | Sam | Urzetta | M/P | Minneapolis GC | Minneapolis | Mn |
| 1951 | Billy | Maxwell | M/P | Saucon Valley CC | Bethlehem | Pa |
| 1952 | Jack | Westland | M/P | Seattle GC | Seattle | Wa |
| 1953 | Gene | Littler | M/P | Oklahoma City G & CC | Oklahoma City | Ok |
| 1954 | Arnold | Palmer | M/P | CC of Detroit | Grosse Pte. Farms | Mi |
| 1955 | E. Harvie Jr. | Ward | M/P | CC of Virginia | Richmond | Va |
| 1956 | E. Harvie Jr. | Ward | M/P | Knollwood Club | Lake Forest | Il |
| 1957 | Hillman Jr. | Robbins | M/P | The Country Club | Brookline | Ma |
| 1958 | Charles R. | Coe | M/P | Olympic Club | San Francisco | Ca |
| 1959 | Jack | Nicklaus | M/P | Broadmoor GC | Colorado Springs | Co |
| 1960 | Deane | Beman | M/P | St Louis CC | Clayton | Mo |
| 1961 | Jack | Nicklaus | M/P | Pebble Beach GL | Pebble Beach | Ca |
| 1962 | Labron E. Jr. | Harris | M/P | Pinehurst CC | Pinehurst | NC |
| 1963 | Deane | Beman | M/P | Wakonda Club | Des Moines | Ia |
| 1964 | William C. | Campbell | M/P | Canterbury GC | Cleveland | Oh |
| 1965 | Robert J. Jr. | Murphy | M/P | Southern Hills CC | Tulsa | Ok |
| 1966 | Gary | Cowan | M/P | Merion CC | Ardmore | Pa |
| 1967 | Bob | Dickson | M/P | Broadmoor GC | Colorado Springs | Co |
| 1968 | Bruce | Fleisher | M/P | Scioto CC | Columbus | Oh |
| 1969 | Steve | Melnyk | M/P | Oakmont CC | Oakmont | Pa |
| 1970 | Lanny | Wadkins | M/P | Waverley CC | Portland | Or |
| 1971 | Gary | Cowan | M/P | Wilmington CC | Wilmington | De |
| 1972 | Marvin III | Giles | M/P | Charlotte CC | Charlotte | NC |
| 1973 | Craig | Stadler | M/P | Inverness Club | Toledo | Oh |
| 1974 | Jerry | Pate | M/P | Ridgewood CC | Ridgewood | NJ |
| 1975 | Fred | Ridley | M/P | CC of Virginia | Richmond | Va |
| 1976 | Bill | Sander | M/P | Bel-Air CC | Los Angeles | Ca |
| 1977 | John | Fought | M/P | Aronimink GC | Newtown Square | Pa |
| 1978 | John | Cook | M/P | Plainfield CC | Plainfield | NJ |
| 1979 | Mark | O'Meara | M/P | Canterbury GC | Cleveland | Oh |
| 1980 | Hal | Sutton | M/P | CC of North Carolina | Pinehurst | NC |
| 1981 | Nathaniel | Crosby | M/P | Olympic Club | San Francisco | Ca |
| 1982 | Jay | Sigel | M/P | The Country Club | Brookline | Ma |
| 1983 | Jay | Sigel | M/P | North Shore CC | Glenview | Il |
| 1984 | Scott | Verplank | M/P | Oak Tree GC | Edmond | Ok |
| 1985 | Sam | Randolph | M/P | Montclair GC | West Orange | NJ |
| 1986 | Buddy | Alexander | M/P | Shoal Creek | Birmingham | Al |
| 1987 | Bill | Mayfair | M/P | Jupiter Hills Club | Jupiter | Fl |
| 1988 | Eric | Meeks | M/P | Hot Springs G & CC | Hot Springs | Va |
| 1989 | Chris | Patton | M/P | Merion CC | Ardmore | Pa |
| 1990 | Phil | Mickelson | M/P | Cherry Hills CC | Denver | Co |
| 1991 | Mitch | Voges | M/P | The Honors Course | Chattanooga | Tn |
| 1992 | Justin | Leonard | M/P | Muirfield Village G.C. | Dublin | Oh |
| 1993 | John | Harris | M/P | Champions GC | Houston | Tx |
| 1994 | Tiger | Woods | M/P | TPC at Sawgrass | Ponte Vedra | Fl |
| 1995 | Tiger | Woods | M/P | Newport GC | Newport | RI |
| 1996 | Tiger | Woods | M/P | Pumpkin Ridge Golf Club | North Plains | Or |
| 1997 | Matthew | Kuchar | M/P | Cog Hill G&CC | Lemont | Il |
| 1998 | Hank | Kuehne | M/P | Oak Hill CC | Rochester | NY |